This blog is about medical education in the US and around the world. My interest is in education research and the process of medical education.

The lawyers have asked that I add a disclaimer that makes it clear that these are my personal opinions and do not represent any position of any University that I am affiliated with including the American University of the Caribbean, the University of Kansas, the KU School of Medicine, Florida International University, or the FIU School of Medicine. Nor does any of this represent any position of the Northeast Georgia Medical Center or Northeast Georgia Health System.

Monday, April 6, 2015

What I learned from a patient

Sorry for the long absence. This blog was written by one of my third year medical students. Please enjoy this reposting done with the student's permission...
The Herbert Wertheim College of Medicine (HWCOM) teaches its students to look beyond a patient’s set of symptoms. Social determinants – social and economic conditions that affect people’s lives and their health – must be taken into account as part of a plan of treatment. Third-year medical student Lisa Podolsky hopes to become a gynecologist/obstetrician. This is her account of a real-life lesson that illustrates why the World Health Organization deems “the social conditions in which people are born, live and work are the single most important determinant of one’s health status.”

By Lisa Podolsky 

Her story started pretty similarly to any other patient I’d had since starting my family medicine rotation. Once the nurse said she had another patient for me, I asked for the name and began looking up previous clinical notes and labs while waiting for her.

She had a history of arthritis, GERD and uncontrolled diabetes – all diagnoses I had become comfortable discussing with patients. Her last follow-up note indicated a plan to obtain x-rays for her knee pain; metformin [an oral diabetes medicine that helps control blood sugar levels] for her diabetes; and health maintenance screenings in the upcoming year.

Although I was confused why she did not have a visit in the previous nine months, I assumed she would have had an x-ray with some answers, and hopefully have lowered her glucose below the previous level of 400.

I was wrong.

The nurse escorted in a lady in gold shoes and a head-to-toe red outfit. As I waited for the nurse to finish taking her vitals, the lady in red began expressing her frustration at how long it took to get an appointment and her worries that her J02 card expired that day. A J02 card is a classification given out to Miami-Dade residents living 100 percent under the federal poverty level, providing them with hospital services without charge.

With her bag of Easter candies and soda in hand, she asked us to check her glucose level as she was concerned how high it had been at the last visit. I wondered why she was eating chocolate and drinking soda if she was concerned about her glucose level. I thought this would clearly be a visit filled with patient education about diabetes, glycemic index and healthier eating habits. As soon as the patient’s vitals were finished, the lady in red began reciting her problems to me: vaginal itching, acid reflux, “sugars”, loss of feeling in her hand, breast pain; the list went on.

When I started asking about each complaint individually, I could not understand how someone had gone unseen with so many symptoms, each of them unaddressed and having worsened in the past year. How could a patient have vaginal itching and discharge for more than a year? How could a patient feel pain and a lump in her breast without telling someone? How could someone with a previous glucose more than 400 stop her metformin? I remember asking her to remove her shoes to check for ulcers, and immediately the smell of the fungal infections in her toenails filled the room. However, with each complaint more of the story unraveled.

She was homeless and could no longer afford Nexium; water and baking soda would have to do for her reflux. If her sister needed to have her toes amputated because her diabetes was so bad, why wasn’t the patient more concerned about her own diet? The candy only cost 50 cents and her food stamps had run out. But why did she stop the metformin if it’s free from Publix? She lost her bus card and had no way to get to Publix.

With each part of the story, her depression became more evident. She tried to commit suicide two months ago, but was unsuccessful; she felt she even failed at dying. She didn’t understand why God kept letting her wake up each morning. Although I’d seen patients with depression most days since I started my rotation, I had never discussed previous suicide attempts. She was the second patient ever to cry to me. I had never seen such hopelessness, and it broke my heart.

Our approach had to change. We were no longer concerned about addressing her acid reflux, arthritis or health maintenance. Our priorities had to be about addressing the most imminent and extreme issues: her suicidal thoughts and diabetes. We had to mobilize the nurses and pharmacy in order to obtain her free metformin in the clinic that day, before the pharmacy closed and her JO2 coverage ran out, and before she fell to the risk of requiring amputation like her sister.

Next step, refer her to a psychiatrist – but that costs money. We discussed with her exactly how she could obtain a Jackson homeless card, so all referrals, tests and medications would be free, and we could see her again.

By the end of the visit, I felt I had just come out of a whirlwind tunnel. Although our assessment and plan at the end of the visit didn’t address everything we had hoped for at the beginning of the visit, I know we helped this patient.

From her, I learned to look beyond a patient’s medical problems, taking into account a person’s psychosocial problems as well. Treatment plans are not “one size fits all.” Understanding this patient’s depression and lack of resources were critical to providing the best possible care. Referrals for x-rays or discussing diet wouldn’t have mattered; she couldn’t afford x-rays and she ate what she could afford.

I learned how to better support an overwhelmed patient who felt hopeless, as well as how to ask for help from the nurses, pharmacist and finance department to address extreme situations. No matter the situation in life, you always have to be adaptable to change, listen for the subtle comments, and prioritize the patient first- as a whole person- not just as a list of medical problems. By listening to her talk about walking to the clinic, and about her missing her family, we were able to probe further into her depression.

Medicine is an ever-changing field, whether it’s the patients, guidelines, economics, medications, or scientific discoveries. Medicine requires knowing how to adapt to change by knowing the whole story, and then working with the resources available. On the seventh day of my family medicine clerkship, the lady in red helped teach me those lessons.


  1. Hello,
    nice blog
    V.N Karazin Kharkiv National University is
    Best School of Medicine where student can easily study MBBS.

  2. Educationinmedicine is an excellent and informative website. Thank you for sharing your pretty nice post about medicine. Largest Auto Fashion Machinery Blog really appreciate your efforts and will be waiting for your next writing.

  3. I do believe all of the ideas you've offered to your post. They are very convincing and will definitely work. Nonetheless, the posts are too short for newbies. May you please lengthen them a little from next time? Thank you for the post.

    Toshiba PVT-375BT

  4. You have shared here a nice experience of your about teaching to the medical students by a patient . Really a nice work done. Thanks for posting your blog with us.I want to share an informative thing about cellulites.Today cellulite is a big problem and people are finding that how to remove cellulite . Cellulite Burned is one of the best way to get the complete solution if you were suffering from this problem.

  5. This comment has been removed by the author.

  6. Education in medicine is an excellent and informative website.

  7. Education in medicine is an excellent and informative website.

  8. thanks yuu..

  9. Obat Bopeng Paling Ampuh

    » Bopeng bekas jerawat susah hilang?

    » Ingin wajah kembali bersih?

    » Ingin tampil cantik tanpa make up?

    » Mencari Obat Bopeng Paling Ampuh?

    Mari kita bahas tuntas masalahnya disini..!!

    Cara Pesan QnC Jelly Gamat

    Harga Masker Spirulina

  10. Thank you for providing shanties to enter the link in order to number one on google
    Obat Kelenjar Getah Bening Resep Dokter
    Obat Ejakulasi Dini
    Manfaat Dan Harga QnC Jelly Gamat
    Thank you very much

  11. MCE Conferences Continuing Medical Education (CME) programs are designed by primary care healthcare professionals who are leaders in their field. Evidence-based, clinically-focused and absolutely commercial-free primary care CME Conferences. Half-day CME sessions at great family friendly destinations. CME does not get better than this -

  12. Modern medicine has several treatments that can aid such episodes, limiting the amount of time that you are down. Still, it is highly recommended that you seek the attention of an orthopaedic doctor, especially if the pain keeps coming back. A visit to the doctor would also help you understand the reason behind it.

    Most common reasons for knee pain.


  14. financial-aid-and-scholarship

  15. it is highly recommended that you seek the attention of an orthopaedic doctor, especially if the pain keeps coming back. If you want a knowledge about Medical education then checkout this website -

  16. Due to our unhealthy lifestyle and diet, we generally become the victim of digestion problems. This is a very common problem and can affect you at any time. Medicines can worsen the situation. I recommend you to try some natural remedies or medications to get instant relief. They will cure your problem permanently.

  17. I really enjoy reading your blog and will be waiting for your next update. I am working for UHSA, UHSA is one of the oldest Caribbean Medical and Nursing Schools. We are committed to educating physicians and health care professionals. For further information please click this link Caribbean medical school

  18. Hey your blog is very nice, such useful information you are sharing. I really like your blog the information is very accurate and if you want to know more about free ad posting service, there is another website with best information.

  19. Nice one. People are becoming aware of this kind of topic and I would like to thank the author for writing this kind of article for the benefit of people.
    Online financial dictionary